Chartered Accountants◆Practising since 2016

India rules · all investors

Share Valuation: India rules for foreign companies

CA Utsav Dogra, Chartered Accountant, ICAI M. No. 542375

FEMA pricing protects against value leaving India cheaply and money arriving at inflated prices. A foreign investor may not subscribe below fair value or sell to a resident above it.

How fair value is worked out

FEMA pricing protects against value leaving India cheaply and money arriving at inflated prices. A foreign investor may not subscribe below fair value or sell to a resident above it.

For unlisted companies, fair value is computed under an internationally accepted pricing methodology on an arm's-length basis, usually a discounted cash flow for operating businesses or net asset value for asset-heavy or early companies. The certificate is issued close to the transaction date.

Income-tax rules separately test share issues and transfers against their own fair market value formulas, so the price should be checked against both sets of rules to avoid a tax adjustment.

When a valuation is needed

  • Fresh issue of shares after incorporation.
  • Rights issues where the investor takes more than its entitlement.
  • Transfers between the parent and an Indian resident.
  • Conversion of loans or instruments into equity.

The FEMA valuation is separate from any valuation the parent prepares for its own financial reporting.

Checklist

  • Choose the valuation method
  • Obtain the certificate near the transaction date
  • Check the income-tax fair value too
  • Fix share numbers against rupee receipts
  • Report in FC-GPR or FC-TRS

Common mistakes

  • Using an old valuation
  • Ignoring the income-tax pricing test
  • Issuing shares on a currency amount, not the rupee receipt
  • Missing FC-TRS on a share transfer

How this applies to your country

Our service: FEMA and RBI reporting

Questions

Who can certify fair value?

Depending on the case, a Chartered Accountant, a SEBI-registered merchant banker or a registered valuer.

Is a valuation needed for a rights issue at face value?

If the foreign investor takes no more than its entitlement on the same terms as residents, the pricing rules are applied differently; check before issuing.

Is a valuation needed at incorporation?

Subscription to the memorandum at face value on incorporation does not need a valuation. Later issues do.

Queries

Send the firm a query

Tell us briefly what you need. A member of the team will get back to you.

We use your details only to respond to your query. See our privacy policy.

Call